The Doctor Check: the #1 Mistake People Make During Medicare Open Enrollment

Medicare’s Annual Enrollment Period is a good time to compare your coverage for next year. But one important check is easy to miss: will your doctors still accept your exact plan in 2027?
A doctor who is in network today may not be in network next year. Provider directories can also lag behind contract changes or show information that does not match your specific plan. Before you enroll, call your doctor’s office directly and ask them to check your plan for the new year.
This matters for people with Medicare Advantage plans in Ocala, The Villages, On Top of the World, Marion County, and across Central Florida. Local contract changes involving Humana and HCA Florida, and UnitedHealthcare and AdventHealth, are reminders to verify, not assume, that your care team will remain in network.
Start with the plan you’ll have next year
Medicare’s Annual Enrollment Period runs from October 15 through December 7. Plan changes made during this period generally take effect January 1. You can review Medicare’s enrollment options and compare plans through Medicare Plan Compare.
For a useful network check, have your 2027 plan information ready. “I have Humana” or “I have UnitedHealthcare” may not be enough. A company can offer different plans with different networks, even in the same county.
Look for the plan’s full name and, if available, its plan or contract number. Then check the doctors and facilities you rely on, including:
Your primary care doctor
Specialists
Hospitals and outpatient clinics
Labs and imaging centers
Pharmacies

Call your doctor’s office directly
A provider directory is a helpful place to start, but it should not be your only check. Directories may not immediately reflect a new contract, a doctor’s affiliation change, or the network details for your exact plan.
Call the doctor’s office and ask:
“I’m checking my Medicare coverage for 2027. Will Dr. [name] accept my exact [plan name] Medicare Advantage plan as in network starting January 1, 2027?”
Ask the office to check the plan for the specific doctor, not just the medical group or hospital. If the office says yes, ask whether it can confirm that in writing or tell you when the information was verified. Write down the date of the call and the name of the person you spoke with.
If the answer is unclear, call the number on your plan’s member ID card and ask the insurer to confirm the doctor’s network status for 2027. You can also check the insurer’s 2027 provider directory. If the office and insurer give different answers, ask both to look up your exact plan and the doctor’s billing group.
Don’t assume the hospital and doctor have the same status
A hospital may be in network while a doctor who practices there is not, or the other way around. That’s why it helps to check each part of your care separately. A hospital’s insurance page also cautions that participation can vary by plan; for example, see HCA Florida Ocala Hospital’s insurance information.
Two local contract changes to keep on your radar
Humana and HCA Florida
Local reporting says Humana Medicare Advantage members may need to check their HCA Florida primary care doctors for 2027. The reported contract change concerns HCA primary care providers. HCA Florida hospitals and specialists were reported to remain in Humana’s network, but that does not prove that a particular doctor is in network for your plan.
If you live in Ocala, Marion County, The Villages, or On Top of the World and have Humana Medicare Advantage, contact your primary care office and Humana. Confirm your doctor’s status for your exact 2027 plan. For local coverage of the situation, see the Ocala Gazette’s Medicare enrollment update.
UnitedHealthcare and AdventHealth
UnitedHealthcare and AdventHealth have announced a contract dispute. AdventHealth says that if an agreement is not reached by December 31, 2026, AdventHealth hospitals, physicians, and other services across Florida will be out of network for United members beginning January 1, 2027. AdventHealth also says that, for now, patients should keep appointments and continue care as usual. The status could change, so check for updates on AdventHealth’s contract information page.
If you have a UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage plan and use AdventHealth, ask both the doctor’s office and UnitedHealthcare about your particular plan. Confirm again closer to January 1 if the contract is still being negotiated.

A practical four-step plan check
Use these steps before you make an enrollment decision:
Make a care list. Write down your doctors, specialists, hospitals, regular labs, pharmacies, and prescriptions.
Check the 2027 plan details. Use Medicare Plan Compare and the plan’s 2027 directory to see what appears to be covered.
Call to confirm. Ask each important doctor’s office whether the doctor will accept your exact plan as in network starting January 1. If anything is unclear, call the insurer.
Choose and enroll by December 7. Compare your options, submit your enrollment request on time, and keep a record of your confirmation.
If you’re meeting with a licensed agent to discuss Medicare Advantage or Part D plan options, you’ll complete a Scope of Appointment (SOA) at the appointment, just before the discussion of plan details begins. It’s a quick form that records which types of products you agreed to discuss; it does not require you to enroll. You can read more in CMS’s Agent and Broker Training and Testing Guidelines.
Check more than the doctor list
Your doctor may be in network, but that does not automatically mean every service connected to that doctor is covered the same way. Ask about referrals, lab work, imaging, and the location where you receive care. Check your prescriptions and preferred pharmacy too, since drug coverage can change when you switch plans.
If you are considering changing from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare, review your options carefully. You may need a separate Part D prescription drug plan, and Medigap enrollment has its own rules and timing. Medicare explains the basic choices on its coverage options page.

Make the call before you choose
The most important question is not simply, “Is my doctor in the directory?” It is: “Will my doctor accept my exact plan in 2027?”
A few calls can help you avoid surprises after January 1. If you are in Ocala, The Villages, On Top of the World, or anywhere else across Central Florida, check each doctor and facility you depend on, and don’t rely on a directory alone. During Annual Enrollment, confirm first, compare your choices, and make any plan change by December 7. If you’d like help working through those calls and comparisons, a licensed local Medicare agent, like Brent Miranda, who serves clients across Central Florida, can help you double-check your list before you enroll.
Comments